NFL Draft 2021: Will The New York Giants Select DeVonta Smith?

Smith is the favorite to go to the Giants, but is that a smart bet?

2021 Heisman trophy DeVonta Smith is generating a lot of buzz in the 2021 NFL Draft. His ceiling is as high as No. 6, but some mock drafts believe that he can fall as low as the mid teens. 

Picking at No. 11, the New York Giants have been linked to the Alabama standout quite a bit as the team looks to continue to be in the market to load up their offense. 

FanDuel Sportsbook has listed Smith as the favorite to be selected by the Giants this Thursday.

Will Smith go to Big Blue? Let’s read some tea leaves and see if the fit is right.

The Case for Smith to be selected by the Giants

If you parse through the betting markets, including this prop, Smith has been linked to the Giants since Draft props have been released. His total has been set at 11.5 for nearly the whole process, making it clear that this spot is an inflection point for Smith. 

New York’s head coach Joe Judge is a former Alabama assistant coach with ties to Nick Saban. That should only help Smith’s case in the Giants war room if he is on the board when New York picks on Thursday.

The Judge connection is not the only reason to tie Smith to NY as Several reporters have linked the team and prospect. ESPN’s Jordan Raanan said this past Sunday that he believes Smith would be the team’s pick if he is around at No. 11. 

Sign up for a new FanDuel account and bet $5 to win $100 if Trevor Lawrence is the 1st pick in the 2021 NFL Draft! (Lawrence's un-boosted odds are -100000!) CLICK HERE to get started!

While the G-Men signed wide receiver Kenny Golladay this offseason, the team can still use more weapons on offense with Saquon Barkley rejoining the team after a torn ACL last season and a big year for third year quarterback Daniel Jones.

The Case against Smith to be selected by the Giants

Smith would add another dynamic threat in the passing game for Jones, but the team can still use help on the offensive line -- with Northwestern’s Rashawn Slater possibly available when the Giants are on the clock. 

As well, another local beat reporter, Dan Duggan of The Athletic, hypothesized in the staff-wide mock draft that the Giants would look towards an edge rusher, despite the needs elsewhere on the roster. 

“Fans will be outraged if the Giants pass on both Alabama wide receivers and Northwestern offensive lineman Rashawn Slater,” Duggan wrote. “But I believe (Giants general manager Dave) Gettleman has his sights set on an edge rusher.” 

Duggan mocked the pick to be Azeez Ojulari, but there have been reports linking the Giants to Penn State’s Micah Parsons as well. 

The root of this pick being anyone but Smith is that he will either be off the board or that the Giants feel that he is a luxury the team doesn’t need. 

While he is the favorite to be selected by the Giants, there are several other needs on this rebuilding NY roster.


I wouldn’t lay the price on Smith right now. He has been linked to the Giants often in the pre-draft process, but I do see too many other options on the board.

Parsons at +600 is an intriguing bet with the amount of times he’s been linked to the organization and defensive line coach Sean Spencer’s connection to Parsons from Happy Valley. 

There is the chance that Smith is off the board by No. 11 anyway, but I see the board shaking out where there are too many quality options to bet this prop at +300. 

As we move further down the board, there is more variance, and there are a lot of moving pieces to take the shortest price. Parsons -- or Duggan’s choice of Ojulari at +1700 -- seem more appealing at this point.

Sign up for a new DraftKings account and bet $1 to win $100 if any quarterback is selected #1 overall! It's a no-brainer! CLICK HERE to get started!

Get Today's Picks